In an article titled "What are Gold Prices Telling Us?", Jim O'Neill, former UK Treasury Minister and Chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management, shares his perspectives on gold prices. Let's delve into the key points he raises:
O'Neill points out that the steep rise in gold prices, even exceeding the gains of the Nasdaq driven by major tech companies, exhibits typical characteristics of bubble behavior. This surge is primarily driven by market momentum, where the fear of missing out exacerbates enthusiasm even with marginal catalysts. However, the question remains whether the justifications supporting this rise hold up.
Historically, holding gold relies on its role as a currency anchor and an inflation hedge. However, O'Neill argues that this logic doesn't explain the sudden surge in gold prices in 2025, especially since the US dollar had already weakened, and US Treasury yields decreased as inflation expectations improved. For this reason, labeling this rise as a bubble is understandable.
O'Neill reflects on his experience in supporting gold during his career in the financial sector. On one occasion, during 1995-1996 when he was Chief Foreign Exchange Strategist at Goldman Sachs, he expressed concern about the rising government debt in the US and other major economies, and the potential for this debt to be inflated away through monetary policies. At that time, buying gold seemed logical.
He also mentions a later period when he was Chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management, where he encouraged researchers and investors to think more broadly about asset allocation, moving beyond traditional benchmarks like "65% stocks and 35% bonds". One of his colleagues designed an interesting "Unconstrained Total Return Model" that included a wider range of assets in the era of floating exchange rates. Intriguingly, the model suggested a baseline gold allocation far higher than what anyone other than "gold bugs" (those holding extreme views driven by conspiracy theories) would deem reasonable.
When they presented this model to seasoned investment professionals and asset allocators, they found the strategy extremely difficult to implement—they considered it too risky and unconventional to gain widespread acceptance. Nevertheless, O'Neill stresses that there’s an interesting subjective dimension to finance and investing, and this perspective might help in understanding the logic of gold bulls today.
Drawing on his background in analyzing foreign exchange markets, O'Neill fully understands why traditional large holders of foreign exchange reserves (particularly China and Russia) would make strategic decisions to increase their gold holdings, and why they would encourage other members of the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) group to do the same. Their intention to create a "non-dollar dominated international monetary system" is no secret.
Perhaps there’s a more mundane explanation. His experience in foreign exchange markets suggests that currencies typically cycle through price deviations based on relative changes in real interest rates: when the Federal Reserve is easing and inflation expectations don’t decline significantly, the dollar weakens; and when the Fed is tightening, the dollar strengthens. This rule seems to apply not only to other major currencies but also to gold prices—where gold will benefit when real interest rates in all the Group of Seven (G7) economies are declining.
In the current context, if the market believes that central banks will ease significantly (or at least not tighten further) even if underlying inflation doesn’t improve, then rising gold prices are consistent with historical patterns.
O'Neill concludes that he cannot judge which of the bearish or bullish views will prevail, nor can anyone else predict the trajectory of gold prices, but he will closely monitor and remain open to what he sees and hears.
Risk Warning: this article represents only the author’s views and is for reference only. It does not constitute investment advice or financial guidance, nor does it represent the stance of the Markets.com platform.When considering shares, indices, forex (foreign exchange) and commodities for trading and price predictions, remember that trading CFDs involves a significant degree of risk and could result in capital loss.Past performance is not indicative of any future results. This information is provided for informative purposes only and should not be construed to be investment advice. Trading cryptocurrency CFDs and spread bets is restricted for all UK retail clients.
